2010 volume 39(7) pages 884 – 899

Cite as:
Juricevic I, Land L, Wilkins A, Webster M A, 2010, "Visual discomfort and natural image statistics" Perception 39(7) 884 – 899

Download citation data in RIS format

Visual discomfort and natural image statistics

Igor Juricevic, Leah Land, Arnold Wilkins, Michael A Webster

Received 23 January 2010, in revised form 1 April 2010

Abstract. Images with excessive energy at medium spatial frequencies (Fernandez and Wilkins, 2008 Perception 37 1098 – 1113), or that have high color contrast and little or no luminance contrast (Wilkins et al, 2008 Perception 37 Supplement, 144 – 145) appear uncomfortable or aversive and can induce headaches in hypersensitive observers. Such stimuli are uncharacteristic of natural images, and we examined whether visual discomfort more generally increases with deviations from the spatial and chromatic properties of natural scenes. Observers rated the level of discomfort or artistic merit in color images generated from noise or random overlapping rectangles (Mondrians). In one set, the slopes of the amplitude spectra for luminance or chromatic contrast were varied independently to create images ranging from strongly blurred to sharpened relative to a ‘natural’ 1/f spectrum. Perceived blur was dominated by the luminance slopes, with discomfort rated lowest for sim1/f spectra. In a second set of focused Mondrians, color was varied along different axes in the L – M versus S – LM chromatic plane. Discomfort ratings were lowest around bluish – yellowish axes that are again typical of natural outdoor scenes. A final set varied in the levels of both luminance and chromatic contrast. Discomfort increased with increasing color contrast or decreasing luminance contrast, and tended toward lower ratings for images with balanced levels of luminance and color contrast. Notably, these ratings of discomfort were not related to judgments of artistic merit. Thus, for both spatial and chromatic content, the least aversive images corresponded to characteristic properties of the natural visual environment, and may reflect a normalization of visual coding to the natural world.

This article has supplementary online material: Colour figures

Restricted material:

PDF Full-text PDF size: 3081 Kb

HTML References  40 references, 31 with DOI links (Crossref)

Your computer (IP address: has not been recognised as being on a network authorised to view the full text or references of this article. If you are a member of a university library that has a subscription to the journal, please contact your serials librarian (subscriptions information).